Politics / Social issues

Standing Behind Canada’s Sex Workers: Bill C-36 and the International Day to End Violence Against Sex Workers

As Canadians gathered to keep vigil in honour of 14 young women murdered at the École Polytechnique in Montreal 25 years ago, sex workers were themselves facing down the barrel of a gun.

On December 6th, a day when the nation calls out all forms of violence against women, Bill C-36 came into effect.  A law which purports to protect sex workers but is, as Madeline Ashby describes it, “not so much a new piece of legislation as a reset button that clarifies the Conservative government’s attitudes toward women, sex, and sex work.”

As Valerie Scott, a former sex worker and one of the women behind the landmark Bedford case, told Canadian Press, “[December 6th] should not solely be for women who were murdered by Marc Lépine, it should also be for women who were murdered by Robert Pickton.”

Thus as Bill C-36 sweeps through our streets, there has never been a more pressing time for Canadians to stand in solidarity with sex workers, particularly as we today observe the International Day to End Violence Against Sex Workers.

Source: The Society Pages

Source: The Society Pages

And it was precisely the prevention of violence against sex workers that prompted the justices of the Supreme Court of Canada to unanimously strike down a series of laws on prostitution in December 2013.  As they rendered their judgment, they found that these laws violated sex workers’ “constitutional rights to freedom of expression, to life, liberty and the security of the person.”

The Bill C-36 hearings followed on the initial December 2013, but were merely a carefully orchestrated parable that sought to cloak social conservatism, misogyny and ‘whorephobia’ in the mantle of feminism.

But during the C-36 hearings, the Government of Canada flippantly ignored the constitutionality of the new law it was proposing, notably of Section 7 of the Charter which protects Canadians’ rights to life, liberty and security of person.

Sex workers march against Bill C-36 in Toronto. Source: CTV

Sex workers march against Bill C-36 in Toronto. Source: CTV

This right includes two things: the right to security of person includes control over one’s bodily integrity.

Women’s bodies have long been battlefields on which politicians of all stripes have waged their wars – with the end game often being about “protecting votes, not women.” But the rights of women – all  women – to control their bodies has also long been at the heart of the feminist struggle.

It is the right we fought for when we demanded the right to safe and legal abortions.  It is what Sue Rodriguez demanded of the Supreme Court of Canada when she asked for the right to die. And, one might argue, it underpinned some of the feminist arguments against the right of the State to control women’s bodies during the Parti Québécois’ Charter of Values debates.

Control over own bodies is sacrosanct and fundamental to ensuring that women are full and equal citizens in the eyes of the law.  And sex work is no different.

And second, as sex work activist and law student Naomi Sayers beautifully argued in her open letter to Ontario Premier Kathleen Wynne, “The goal of any gender equality bill should not be making something unsafe in an effort to abolish it.”

Sex workers march in Turkey. Source: genderacrossborders.com

Sex workers march in Turkey. Source: genderacrossborders.com

It was clear that the government’s intent was not to protect sex workers, but rather to placate the Conservative Party’s political base.

Case in point: “Of course we don’t want to make life safer for prostitutes, we want to do away with prostitution. That’s the intent of the bill,” said Conservative Senator Donald Plett.

And when Bill C-36 received royal assent, sex workers rallied to initiate a massive letter-writing campaign to demand that Premier Wynne take a long hard look at the constitutionality of the law.

It didn’t take long for Premier Wynne to put the Government of Canada on notice, writing:

“I have listened to the debate that has taken place over the last year, and particularly since the introduction of Bill C-36. And I am left with grave concern that the so-called Protection of Communities and Exploited Persons Act will protect neither ‘exploited persons’ nor ‘communities. (…) I am not an expert, and I am not a lawyer, but as premier of this province, I am concerned that this legislation (now the law of the land) will not make sex workers safer. (…) We must enforce duly enacted legislation, but I believe that we must also take steps to satisfy ourselves that, in doing so, we are upholding the constitution and the Charter.”

And so let us join sex workers on the front lines to demand laws that will ensure that their fundamental right to safety and bodily integrity is respected. Let us stand with sex workers to demand an end to state-sanctioned marginalization of women and the enshrinement of violence in the law, and to echo sex workers’ demand for their Charter rights.

Source: Public Service Alliance of Canada/British Columbia

Source: Public Service Alliance of Canada/British Columbia

Let us take a moment of silence for the women of Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside, who died at the hands of Robert Pickton, but also at the hands of our own indifference.  Women like activist Sereena Abotsway, who spoke up on behalf of the women she worked with when her colleagues began disappearing from the streets of Vancouver.  Or Marnie Lee Anne Frey, a beloved daughter who would call home up to eight times a day.  And Georgina Faith Papin, a mother of seven, “a ball of fire with a heart of gold.”

Let us refuse to allow our government to consolidate the basis of their political on the bodies of women and affirm the value of all women, whether they are transgendered, Indigenous, Black, immigrant, or poor.

Because whether it comes from a bad date or from our own government, violence inflicted on a sex worker is an attack on us all.

In memory and in honour of Amy Paul, my neighbour and fellow citizen of Ottawa’s Vanier district. 

You May Also Be Interested In…

Remembering École Polytechnique and the State of Violence Against Women in Canada

Bill C-36 – The Time a Conservative MP Used a Woman’s Rape Story to Serve His Political Agenda

3 thoughts on “Standing Behind Canada’s Sex Workers: Bill C-36 and the International Day to End Violence Against Sex Workers

  1. Hi, I am Star. I am a 21 year old escort from Toronto.

    The new prostitution law is a ridiculous waste time and money. I’ve read articles where it says what money Peter Mackay offered police, they said is not enough.

    Currently things are fine the way they are. Police watch for new ads & occasionally do routine check ups on escorts by booking fake appointments. I provide Government id, they check for warrants and off they go.

    What I choose to do with my time and body is my choice. Now obviously certain rules like no under age girls, no public encounters, and nothing near schools is proper.

    I would have no problem paying for licensing if it was enforced, at least then then at least then there isn’t worry about underage girls. Doing thing like providing license number to post the ad would help regulate things.

    The new law is supposed to make things safer, but in reality things will only get far worse. Legalizing prostitution but yet making it illegal for anyone to make the choice by contacting us threw ads we post is a silly excuse to arrest or charge people and therefore a waste of tax payers money that should be put to more important issues. Forcing us to go to public areas and clubs to roam out of our comfort zone, when really it should be privately conducted behind closed doors. As we are consenting adults, what we risk and do what we in our personal lives is none of anyone else’s concern or choice, unless obviously harm was done. In this situation we should be comfortable calling police as I have done before, but not anymore with the new law in place.

    Abuse happens anyone and to those who let it happen/continue. Good meaningful relationships are hard to come by these days. Most people are caught up in work life & look for the occasion for companionship instead.

    Johns should be comfortable reporting an underage or pimped girls forcing police to do all the research New Prostitution Law. Really this should be embraced.

    And there you have it, another happy hooker.


    Sincerely, Star.

    • Thank you for sharing, Star. I agree with you whole-heartedly: “What I choose to do with my time and body is my choice.” <3

  2. Pingback: Stephen Harper and the ‘moral panic’ over the niqab and women’s Charter rights | Elle Beaver

Leave a comment...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s